Glenn Greenwald faces pushback against PRISM revelations

http://twitter.com/#!/brithume/status/345717256803729408

The Guardian’s Glenn Greenwald today posted a lengthy article detailing some of the fallout, both personal and political, from his reporting on the National Security Agency’s PRISM program. While Greenwald promises that what has been reported so far is just the tip of the iceberg of the administration’s surveillance activities, his claim that the NSA has “direct access” to the servers of nine Internet companies seems to be falling apart.

The CEOs of both Facebook and Google issued statements denying that claim of “direct access,” and technical experts are backing up that claim with their independent analysis. ZDNet’s Ed Bott concludes in a piece today that “the botched reporting by the Guardian and the [Washington] Post means that millions of readers directed their anger at a handful of big companies that were unfairly accused of selling out their customers to the national security apparatus.”

Kevin Drum of Mother Jones concurs, arguing that Greenwald seems to have misinterpreted the PowerPoint slide deck claiming “direct access” to “servers.” Rick Perlstein of The Nation concurs.

http://twitter.com/#!/thenation/status/345724895289831425
http://twitter.com/#!/Auriandra/status/345720324647686144

The Guardian, through other reporters, has walked back the “direct access” story.

http://twitter.com/#!/axenicely/status/345617474571620353
http://twitter.com/#!/KelsieInKC/status/345748541261631488
http://twitter.com/#!/ChristianStork/status/345180285886930944
http://twitter.com/#!/TheScottFinley/status/345153562302636032

Read more: http://twitchy.com/2013/06/14/glenn-greenwald-faces-pushback-against-prism-revelations/

Leave a Reply